August 12, 2011

Catholic Mass in Italy and USA compared

Some differences represent possible improvements both ways.
Only practical differences are considered here, with no references to the Latin Rite (Roman Rite in both cases).

Often in the USA and not so in Italy (in chronological order):
  1. Masses are concentrated in early morning instead of evening.
  2. Piano is more common than organ.
  3. A separate soundproof room with audio connection and big windows is available on one side of the Church.
  4. Missals are distributed at the beginning and collected at the end instead of leaflets available on pews.
  5. The celebrant starts his homily with a quip.
  6. People laughs openly (=higher participation versus respectful attitude).
  7. People are sometimes asked questions by show of hands.
  8. Readings, prayers and Mass formulas in English are much more direct and explicit than in Italian.
  9. The celebrant uses a radio microphone and moves freely in front of the altar instead of standing at the pulpit.
  10. Sometimes the collection basket is passed from hand to hand by rows.
  11. Collections can be two: for the church and for the poor.
  12. People queue to take the Eucharist by rows, not forming a line from random seats.
  13. Children who do not take the Eucharist going to the altar are blessed.
  14. Wine in a small glass cup is also offered in a separate line.
  15. Final announcements at the end are long and boring everywhere.
  16. Anniversaries are celebrated by applause at the end of the Mass.
  17. The celebrant moves to the main exit and greets the parishioners.
  18. A specified second collection is asked for at the end of the Mass.
  19. In hot places (Hawaii, Puerto Rico) air conditioning is pumped up.
  20. In Puerto Rico, previously recorded music is played in the background at some moments.
  21. Sometimes in response to "God be with you", it is said "And with your Spirit", sometimes "And also with You"
Further points may be added to this page as comments. Thank you.